Sarah Carter’s long-term relationship with Yoga teacher Kishan Shah started in 2007 and continued till 2010 when they finally decided to separate due to irreconcilable differences. Sarah Michelle Prinze [2] ( née Gellar / ˈɡɛlər / GHEL-ər; born April 14, 1977 [3]) is an American actress. After being spotted at the age of four in New York City, she made her acting debut in the television film An Invasion of Privacy (1983).